State Rep. Dwayne Bohac, R-Houston filed a bill in the Texas legislature that is expected to receive bipartisan support to help religious-minded teachers and schools use holiday greetings like “Merry Christmas” and “Happy Hanukkah” and to “display Christmas trees, Nativity scenes, menorahs and other cultural icons of winter celebrations”.
So technically a Wiccan teacher, could erect a Yule tree (Christmas tree), a straw Yule goat, and eat a Yule Boar (Christmas ham) in honor of the Solstice and the pagan god Odin. Ironically if there were such a teacher, that person would most likely not do any of those things knowing that it would offend the religious majority of their parents.
Sort of the way, Bohac was offended when his son came home telling him that the teacher has erected a holiday tree with holiday ornaments.
“After inquiring with school officials as to why the term ‘Holiday Tree’ was being used, it became apparent that the school was fearful of litigation,” Bohac said. “It was that moment that inspired me to file legislation that would provide students, parents, teachers and administrators a safe harbor for openly celebrating a Federal holiday.”
One has to wonder how offended he would have been if his son’s teacher was a pagan, and they honored Odin during Yule. Aside from nativity scenes there isn’t one popular Christmas ritual that doesn’t have a pagan origin.
I’m sure some of the pagans were a bit miffed too about having their Thor’s Oak replaced by the tradition of a Christmas tree. It’s also curious how Christians erect Christmas trees, given that Jeremiah 10:1-10 expressly forbids this particular pagan practice. A Christian legend was concocted which attributed the demise of the pagan tree to St. Boniface, an eighth century missionary to Germany. After just one chop of his holy axe, a mighty wind blew down Thor’s tree. The credulous pagans were impressed and amazed and thereafter they celebrated Christmas, or so the story goes.
If only they could have filed legislation to protect their cherished religious beliefs from succumbing to the popularity of a new belief. They didn’t really have a say back then because religion was dictated by the state. Which in a roundabout way is exactly what Bohac is doing with his bill.
Yes he leaves it up to teachers and schools to choose which religious tradition to follow. Realistically in a majority Christian country, I’m betting on more mangers than menorahs. The few brave souls celebrating different traditions can either try to buck the majority or just give up and say “Merry Christmas!”
So again Jesus’s birth will be celebrated boldly in Texas public schools funded by taxpayers of different faiths or no faith. The people with the dominant religious belief will determine what holiday is celebrated. The Christian ruling class will be able to promote their religious beliefs and drown out different religious beliefs. The Jewish students in my classroom, who talked about their traditions when we were reading A Christmas Carol from a secular perspective, will be de facto second class citizens.
Except in a neighborhood where a minority religion like Islam is the most popular. Imagine the Christian outrage then. Imagine it when they no longer have the numbers to be the ruling class. Their best hope in that scenario is that the next religious ruling class keeps their religious beliefs out of government.
*Update. I posted a link to the post to Rep. Dwayne Bohac’s Facebook page. Let’s see if he will address the criticism of what he calls “The Merry Christmas Bill”. Maybe he could at least put Happy Hanukkah in parenthesis next to the name of his bill right? Just to show this isn’t about promoting Christianity over all other religious traditions of his constituents.
If you like go on over there and give your opinion. My opinion: civil and articulate opinions will accomplish the most.
17 thoughts on “If only more schools could display more nativity scenes and menorahs…”
Strangely, we don’t see any wannabe St. Bonifaces running up to “Holiday” trees taking a single holy swipe with an ax to convert us all to Christianity.
display… Nativity scene,
Hmmm…methinks this violates the second commandment, no?
I think you mean the First Amendment, unless the nativity scene involves handguns . . .
Methinks the 2nd commandment and and the 2nd amendment are different things, yes?
2nd Commandment: No “graven” images. Meaning no “earthly” representations of god. And since Jesus is supposed to be god incarnate…oopsie.
Of course, the Catholics dispensed with that one a while back. They split up the “coveting” part in order to get back o 10.
This is the reasoning to get around the 1st Amendment…
I am Jewish, and yes, I always did feel like a second class citizen when Christmas came around.
Regardless, I would hate to see either an antiseptic schoolyard devoid of acknowledgement or even honoring of any religion, and devoid of acknowledgement or even honoring of any of the cultures that make up society.
And yes again, I would prefer to leave that in the hands of the local school than as some legislation crafted far away and monitored.
By experience with local schools is that in 2012 they are remarkably understanding and encouraging of diversity, and I would prefer to leave it in their hands along with the PTA and accepting the occasional error, than place it in the hands of bureaucrats that will definitely error in favor of lawyer approved watered down pablum.
Being a second class citizen at Christmas really wasn’t that big of a deal. I do appreciate your looking out for me.
I still keep kosher, I still am very Jewish, and I still love to see Christmas lights.
I was raised a Christian, and born after prayer was removed from schools in the 1970s. Despite that I still remember singing a song thanking god for my school lunch, and Christmas celebrations. I did not experience them from the point of view of someone who celebrated something different. However, schools have become more secular, and I have taught Jewish students, who are more emboldened by that, to talk about what they celebrate at that time. Secularism is a good thing Despite that here in Texas I have been in public schools that have proclamations about Jesus at the front desk during Christmas time. The school I taught at had a sizable and vocal Jewish community, so something like that would be called out. Children from religious minority traditions or nonreligious children in majority Christian schools are not always that lucky.
The nativity is actually a pagan symbol as well. Mary and the baby Jesus were preceded by Isis and the infant Horus, which is a motif found throughout ancient Egyptian artwork.
Just wish to say your article is as astounding. The clarity in your post is simply excellent and I could assume you are an expert on this subject. Well with your permission allow me to grab your feed to keep updated with forthcoming post. Thanks a million and please keep up the rewarding work.
I wanted to send you a bit of note to be able to give thanks over again with the magnificent techniques you’ve contributed here. This has been really pretty generous of you to deliver openly all a few people could have distributed as an e-book to generate some profit on their own, and in particular considering that you could have tried it in case you considered necessary. The techniques likewise served like the fantastic way to recognize that someone else have a similar dream similar to my very own to figure out more and more regarding this condition. I believe there are several more pleasant instances up front for individuals that check out your site.
I think this is among the most vital info for me. And i’m glad reading your article. But should remark on some general things, The site style is wonderful, the articles is really excellent : D. Good job, cheers
Thanks for your whole work on this site. Betty take interest in conducting investigation and it’s really simple to grasp why. We all learn all concerning the powerful manner you make both interesting and useful tips and tricks via your web blog and in addition invigorate response from the others on the point so our simple princess is now discovering a lot. Have fun with the remaining portion of the new year. You’re conducting a splendid job.
Pretty section of content. I just stumbled upon your web site and in accession capital to assert that I acquire actually enjoyed account your blog posts. Anyway I’ll be subscribing to your feeds and even I achievement you access consistently rapidly.
A lot of thanks for your whole labor on this web site. Kate really likes setting aside time for investigation and it’s obvious why. Many of us learn all of the lively way you produce important tactics on your web site and as well as boost response from other individuals on that article plus our own daughter is now being taught a lot. Take pleasure in the rest of the new year. You are always conducting a really great job.
L’analyse de King elle révèle la solidarité morale de techniques scientifiques hétérogènes. Mais elle n’est pas suffisante pour décrire le mélange de peur et de méfiance avec lequel nous recevons les alertes contre les grippes pandémiques. Certes, nous ne croyons plus que la vaccination va nous guérir universellement contre les maladies nouvelles ; mais nous croyons que ces maladies sont dangereuses lorsqu’on nous montre qu’elles émergent chez des cochons mexicains ou des poulets asiatiques.